Wikipedia:Peer review/Olfactory reference syndrome/archive1
Olfactory reference syndrome[edit]
Toolbox |
---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
Rationale for peer review request:
- this is a psychiatric disorder and I am not a psychiatrist,
- neither do I have any real experience editing articles that are about psychiatric disorders,
- Previously a short "start" class article, I have promoted to B class now
- perhaps I would like to take this article to GAN next.
N.B.
- there were very limited secondary and tertiary sources available which met WP:MEDRS, most info is in the form of case reports & I have tried to avoid these wherever possible. We have 4 reviews (2 calling themselves systematic) and 1 book chapter that are used extensively to form the basis of the article.
- I believe there are one or 2 primary sources to support some very obvious content that I felt was required, but could not find any secondary source for.
- Given the paucity of sources, I took the liberty of extending MEDDATE to about 10 years (or more in a few cases) instead of last 5 years.
- Have used the MEDMOS layout for diseases, disorders and syndromes. Not sure if this is the norm for psych articles, and not sure it is entirely appropriate for this condition.