User:S Marshall/RfC close log/Archive3

Archives: 1-50 | 51-100 | 101-150 | 151-200

This page is an archive. Do not edit the contents of this page. Please direct any additional comments to User talk:S Marshall. Thank you!

Index	Close	Date
101	On crime and immigration in Germany	17 October 2019
102	What should we say about the Irish Control of Economic Activity (Occupied Territories) bill in our article about Israeli settlements in Palestine?	20 October 2019
103	What do we mean by "transgender"?	21 October 2019
104	Whether to include a Steve Bannon quote in our article on right-wing populism	23 October 2019
105	On redirects and piped links	8 November 2019
106	Concerning media bias against Jeremy Corbyn	18 November 2019
107	About vehicles derived from the space shuttle	21 March 2020
108	Concerning media coverage of Bernie Sanders	21 March 2020
109	Should we use diacritics in New Zealand English?	21 March 2020
110	On the various names of Peppermint	21 March 2020
111	Is this featured article biased?	23 March 2020
112	Which image should we use to represent cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome?	25 March 2020
113	On the US Republican Party and the Southern Strategy	26 March 2020
114	Should we implement a moratorium on page move proposals relating to COVID-19?^[1]	26 March 2020
115	Concerning Qasem Soleimani and Iranian propaganda	27 March 2020
116	How many names should appear on the list of oldest living people?	28 March 2020
117	On the genre columns in our lists of films	29 March 2020
118	Does Queen Elizabeth II have a surname?	31 March 2020
119	Regarding protests and petitions about Julian Assange^[2]	2 April 2020
120	In which venue should we discuss rcat templates?	4 April 2020
121	What should we do about April Fools' jokes on the Main Page	27 May 2020
122	A conflict between Western sources and Chinese state TV^[3]	5 June 2020
123	On religion in Albania^[4]	10 June 2020
124	Did the FBI try to entrap Michael Flynn?	10 June 2020
125	About one-sided elections	13 June 2020
126	Are "upper caste" and "forward caste" synonymous?	14 June 2020
127	This one reeked of feet	15 June 2020
128	On how to start an article	15 June 2020
129	Concerning the Jordanian annexation	17 June 2020
130	Regarding Joe Biden's fingers^[5]	18 June 2020
131	On the historical reliability of the Daily Mail	19 June 2020
132	About finding aids^[6]	20 June 2020
133	Regarding the shooting of Ahmaud Arbery	24 June 2020
134	Is NXT a world championship?	25 June 2020
135	What to say about the officers involved in the killing of George Floyd	26 June 2020
136	On the prestige of colleges and universities^[7]	27 June 2020
137	On television program(me)s	3 July 2020
138	What to say about George Floyd's criminal past in the article about his killing?	3 July 2020
139	Whether to mention COVID-19 in the lead of our article about Donald Trump	5 July 2020
140	How to describe publications that are no longer being produced?^[8]	6 July 2020
141	Shall we call Mr Wrestling II a sex offender?	11 July 2020
142	Concerning Arab Christians	16 July 2020
143	Is Apple Daily a reliable source?	19 July 2020
144	On the Islamization of East Jerusalem under Jordanian rule	21 July 2020
145	Is PETA a reliable source?	15 September 2020
146	Which music file should we use for the national anthem of the People's Republic of China?	16 September 2020
147	Did the CIA murder Kiki Camarena?	17 October 2020
148	How did Jeffrey Epstein die?	19 October 2020
149	On the reliability of the Huffington Post	20 October 2020
150	On the reliability of the Daily Mail	27 October 2020

Notes[edit]

^ Close subsequently reviewed and endorsed here
^ Close subsequently reviewed and endorsed here
^ Close review here; not formally closed, but archived with unanimous endorsement, on 14 June 2020
^ Close review here; not formally closed, but archived with unanimous endorsement, on 21 June 2020
^ Discussion reviewed on the administrator's noticeboard, and archived without formal result (but with a simple majority to endorse)
^ Close amended on the same day, following an appeal on my talk page
^ Discussion relisted after this RfC close review; and as this is my userspace I feel entitled to note that I think El C's closing statement there demonstrates a profound misunderstanding of how the community deals with disputed closes, but what can you do?
^ re-closed same day following an appeal on my talk page

[1] Close subsequently reviewed and endorsed here

[2] Close subsequently reviewed and endorsed here

[3] Close review here; not formally closed, but archived with unanimous endorsement, on 14 June 2020

[4] Close review here; not formally closed, but archived with unanimous endorsement, on 21 June 2020

[5] Discussion reviewed on the administrator's noticeboard, and archived without formal result (but with a simple majority to endorse)

[6] Close amended on the same day, following an appeal on my talk page

[7] Discussion relisted after this RfC close review; and as this is my userspace I feel entitled to note that I think El C's closing statement there demonstrates a profound misunderstanding of how the community deals with disputed closes, but what can you do?

[8] re-closed same day following an appeal on my talk page

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]