User:Cessaune/LGBTQ+/MOS:GENDERID

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

In my humble opinion, MOS:GENDERID is not inline with WP:NOTCENSORED.

For the sake of example, let's use a notable person, Caitlyn Jenner, and place them in a ficitional situation.

Caitlyn, a biological male, transitioned in 2016. Before then, she was known as Bruce Jenner. More importantly, she was notable under this name, having won an Olympic event and an event in the Pan American Games.

If Jenner were to declare that she was against the use of her former name, it wouldn't matter in a Wikipedia context. She's notable as Bruce, and it would go against GENDERID

But, what if she wasn't notable pre-transition? What if she

It makes no sense to hold transgender people to a different standard than everyone else.