Talk:Scott Storch

Content

Well, this page seems to have any number of problems. I draw attention specifically to the sentence under early life:

"He is currently engaged to 18 year old female, Chase King-Anderson, a fine young thing from the best coast, the west coast."

This needs to go.

-Chris —Preceding unsigned comment added by 129.2.228.49 (talk) 02:52, 20 October 2007 (UTC)

MTV

a large portion of this article seems to be stolen from MTV.com's biography, which is credited to Jason Birchmeier, All Music Guide. is this ok? see MTV's Bio

Nope, not ok. I've deleted it. hateless 03:46, 18 January 2006 (UTC)

aguilera "FUSS" source

The claim that Aguilera has a song dissing him and blah blah whatever...the given citation just goes to the starpulse.com main page, not any article in particular. I'd like a real source for this part of the article because it's interesting.

If you check out the lyrics of the song "FUSS" you will find out that she mention all tracks which were produced by Scott Storch, so its pretty much obvious she is addressing this song to Scott Storch, unless you have a better explanation for it

84.58.41.47 10:43, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

Jewish?

Is Scott Storch a Jew ?

yes, he is. He had a label, "TuffJew" or something.

i find the phrase "a Jew" offensive and would prefer if the question was phrased as "Is he Jewish?" —Preceding unsigned comment added by 64.73.44.244 (talk) 18:47, 15 October 2007 (UTC)

Twenty bucks says this person is not a Jew. I'm a Jew and that kike is a Jew too, challah back. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 202.170.84.2 (talk) 03:06, 15 March 2008 (UTC)

He is a tuff Jew at that. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 67.177.25.203 (talk) 07:51, 3 February 2008 (UTC)

Cry Me A River

I remember MTV showing studio production clips of Cry Me A River before the album was released. I only remember seeing Justin and Timbaland in the studio for this song. Timbaland is b-boxing on the track. Where was Storch? I didn't see him yet he claims this song is his? The tune and the melody sounds like it's Timbaland's. Come on now. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 72.5.167.10 (talk) 22:59, 24 April 2007 (UTC).

--- ans.: Timbaland hired scott storch to co produce a couple of track off justified, cry me a river was one of them. Storch did the piano melody or something and timbaand did some other parts. The credits on the album only state Timbaland though.

I removed a sentence in the article

Shortly after the release, Timbaland finally confessed to the world that Scott Storch is the better producer.

I removed it because I highly doubt Timbaland would say this and I couldn't find anything about it. volumesoxxs 09:20, 16 June 2007 (UTC)

MySpace pages

I deleted the links to the myspace pages because none of those are actually Scott Storch's. They contain songs that arent produced by Scott.

I keep track of the only genuine discography on the web; http://storchaveli.net/discography/ Prodinho 08:44, 21 August 2007 (UTC)

Page Copyright violation

henry 06:15, 1 November 2007 (UTC) it need Gnu free license citations and i don't like starch so im not gonna do it

• The page this article is supposed to have copied actually admits that it used the text under the GNU Free Documentation License from Wikipedia. They copied us, not the other way around. --Metropolitan90 06:52, 1 November 2007 (UTC)

WikiProject class rating

This article was automatically assessed because at least one WikiProject had rated the article as start, and the rating on other projects was brought up to start class. BetacommandBot 15:47, 10 November 2007 (UTC)

Lawsuit

He lost a lawsuit I think it should be mentioned in the text Here's a link: [1] —Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.155.196.231 (talk) 13:20, 22 February 2008 (UTC)

Image

Honestly, I think the image should be either removed or different. It's also depicts spam, for the image has a MySpace link to a different person. --Esanchez_{(Talk 2 me or Sign here)} 22:11, 4 March 2008 (UTC)

I assume you're talking about whatever photo he originally had up for his page, how about this one? http://blog.remixhotel.com/atlanta/category/rhatl-day-2/ Mcnichoj (talk) 07:19, 23 April 2008 (UTC)

mario winans, timati: forever

ok, does anyone know why and how, fat joe as well, mario came into contact with timati? I was totally surprised when I found out. Mario winans actually sings Russian as well on the "forever" track, which is supposedly produced by scott storch. Now i see that storch also produces or produced for fat joe. Does storch have links to the Old Country by anyone's knowledge? I hope someone can clarify. Mallerd (talk) 00:09, 27 August 2008 (UTC)

Indian/Middle East Influence

Yeah you can hear it in a lot of his songs but some of the ones in the list really don't sound Indian or Middle Eastern to me at all. The one that stood out the most to me is Poppin' Them Thangs, I don't know most of the other songs well enough to comment. Oh and that thing about Ciara's new album is there twice. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 203.212.130.251 (talk) 12:29, 21 December 2008 (UTC)

Incorrect Tone

The tone of this article is not appropriate for an enyclopedia. Also, it is not presented from an impartial view at all. Here is the Dr. Dre section:

It was in " ", ---- that Scott went to la to meet the infamous Dr. Dre. A long time fan of Dre, Scott knew that it could be the opportunity of a lifetime. Scott spent the next few years on the west coast working with Dr. Dre and just about every other west coast hip-hop act conceivable, the result, countless credits, deep friendships and his signature on the now infamous Chronic 2001 album. Scott has referred to this as one of the best times of his life. His gratitude for the friendships that developed, the education he received, or the credibility of these joint accomplishments between Scott and others is something that Storch holds close to the heart.

Obviously, this needs to be corrected. Metalb (talk) 22:42, 2 December 2009 (UTC)

Conflicting articles/references about nationality and birthplace.

I am closing this RfC without any result. Very few uninvolved editors participated in this RfC. If this is still unresolved, and you would like to create a new RfC, please follow the instructions at Wikipedia:Requests for comment#Statement should be neutral and brief so that uninvolved editors are more likely to participate in the RfC.

Cunard (talk) 01:18, 22 September 2019 (UTC)

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

---

The reference source for his birthplace is a very poorly written article, and it incorrectly states that Storch was born in Long Island, when his IMDB page (referenced for other parts), states he was born in Nova Scotia.

I'm not going to edit this, but somebody should fix it! —Preceding unsigned comment added by 209.121.120.181 (talk) 06:53, 8 October 2010 (UTC)

Actually, the article in question was published in the Miami New Times, a reputable alternative weekly with high journalistic standards. IMDB, on the other hand, is completely opaque -- no one knows where the site obtained its information. The Miami New Times writer subsequently indicated in a blog post that his source is Scott Storch's mother (who doesn't "know where the people on the Internet got that" notion that Storch was born in Canada). Storch himself is amused by this quasi-meme, and stated emphatically in an interview that he was born in Long Island. This should undoubtedly end the discussion. Indeed, any further attempts to change his birthplace to "Canada" should be considered vandalism, and promptly removed. Jhw57 (talk) 14:19, 21 December 2010 (UTC)

I'm forced to revive this post because of User:Binksternet and also because I want to follow Mr. User:Robert McClenon's advice when this inevitably ends up ANI, evidenced by Binksternet's allegations that were made without the most trivial research. Without further ado I will paste the content from Dispute Resolution and also request an RfC to the below: 70.74.141.203 (talk) 23:37, 31 July 2019 (UTC)

I have an issue with User:Binksternet who reverted my edits and alleged that I was vandalising the page, which could not be further from the truth.

Looking at the edit history, it seems he inappropriately reverted one edit here:

[2]

when I restored the correct version, he stated I'm vandalising:

[3]

From what I can see, Scott Storch himself says in his latest biopic vignette that he "left home" to move to Philadelphia after realising his piano skills.

Further, the multiple sources, which include a reputable Scholar (Maxine Leeds Craig, whose book was published by Oxford University Press), CBS, XXL (magazine), Source (magazine) and also Storch's own linkedin (where he states his education was from Nova Scotia Community College), it is clear Storch was born in Canada.

It seems there is a gross overreliance on a single Miami New Times article that claims he is not Canadian, which itself defers to a single interview from a weak source (allhiphop.com) to support their claim. However, that article is questionable at best given the circumstances surrounding Storch at that point of his career.

I am asking RfC (for now, then ANI) to give their own input on this matter. I think it is unfair to say the multiple sources all stating the same thing (Born, and seemingly partially raised, in Canada) are incorrect, in gross deference to one article that is actually *older* than the ones that I've shared.

What spurred the MNT article was an interview with Brooke Hogan stating her surprise he's Canadian. It seems hard to believe she would lie about something like this.

My sources are different than the ones questioned by the MNT. Also, the tone of the BLOG POST is seemingly derisory, created with the intent of stating "too cool to be Canadian".

I think my sources make it better,

Have you tried to resolve this previously?

Again, I do not think using the talk page here will be helpful, since Binksternet is intent on relying on a single source that cites an allhiphop.com interview with questionable content.

How do you think we can help?

There are a few facts here. First, Storch's LinkedIn states very clearly he attended Nova Scotia Community College (NSCC).

Miami New Times' article relies solely on this interview as their basis for stating he is not Canadian. In fact, in this allhiphop.com interview, Storch allegedly stated he had "never been to Canada in my life".

If Storch had never been to Canada, even up until that point, why does his LinkedIn state he attended NSCC? The allhiphop.com interview is extremely questionable to the point where I ask the audience to analyse my sources and compare it to the single source refuting his birthplace.

To me, it seems clear that the interview and the MNT article depending on it are incorrect, and that Brooke Hogan was originally correct in stating he is Canadian (even if she had no proof).

Many years later I feel there is sufficient proof to now substantiate the claim he is from Canada. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 70.74.141.203 (talk) 19:00, 31 July 2019 (UTC)

Summary of dispute by Binksternet

Far too much conjecture by 70.74.141.203, with a college location somehow stretched into a birth location, with no explicit sourcing making the connection. Instead, the sources are quiet about supposed birth details in Canada, with none of the ones saying Storch is Canadian explaining his birth or early life in that context. The writer Maxine Leeds Craig gives no explanation why she refers to Storch on page 180 of her 2014 book, Sorry I Don't Dance, as "a Jewish-Canadian" musician – there's nothing at all about Storch's birth or early life or anything else about him in her book. (I think she was looking at Storch's Wikipedia bio in 2013.] In 2016, Storch was asked by N.O.R.E. on Drink Champs (video segment from 3:55 to 4:06) whether he was originally from Philadelphia, and Storch said, "No, I was born in New York, on Long Island, but I moved to Florida as an infant, and then when I was 15 I moved with my father, my dad, to Philly..."

As far as I can tell, the hoax about Storch being from Canada was first introduced in 2012 by an IP editor from Alberta, with this change. The change was unreferenced, but instead of being reverted, which it should have been, it was cemented in place by the next few editors establishing wikilinks and categories of Canadian background. A couple of months later, an IP editor from Vienna tried to correct the problem starting with this edit, but the correction was reverted at the beginning of 2013. So the biography has been messed up since then, with circular reporting making the problem worse. See XKCD Citogenesis.

As such, I will continue to remove any hoax about Canada from Storch's biography. Binksternet (talk) 19:48, 31 July 2019 (UTC)

It's interesting to note that the initial hoaxer IP, Special:Contributions/24.222.161.49, and the person filing this DR case, Special:Contributions/70.74.141.203, are both from Alberta, Canada. Some of the other Wikipedia contributors who have asserted that Storch is from Canada are single-use throwaway accounts, who have contributed nothing else. Looks like somebody really trying hard to set the hoax in place. Binksternet (talk) 20:02, 31 July 2019 (UTC)

Scott Storch discussion

Talk: Scott Storch

did User:Binksternet even look up that IP address before making his allegations? First of all, it's not from Edmonton, it's from Nova Scotia.

So it's not me. You are quite eager to point the finger at me. You are wrong on many points which I will summarise here first.

1. I am not that IP editor, who is from Nova Scotia.
2. The "Hoax" you claim is not one at all, and in fact the Miami New Times article you've deferred to even mentions that it was on Wikipedia prior to the article being written, which is dated in 2010: [4]

edit: Per this diff (mid-2006, before Brooke Hogan was on record stating he's Canadian on 6 december 2006, to early 2010, the date of the Miami New Times article) Storch was accepted as being Canadian: [5]

Did you even read the Miami New Times article? The change was made far before 2012. It was made before 2010, which is what prompted the Miami New Times article in the first place.

Brooke Hogan is on record saying Scott Storch is Canadian, and that was the basis of calling Storch Canadian on Wikipedia up until early 2010. Not 2012. But UNTIL 2010.

Lastly, you claim I am making a conjecture? Look at your citation! you're citing a YOUTUBE video where everyone is inebriated beyond belief. It is a poor source.

Again, if Storch had never been to Canada as the allhiphop.com interview claims (and is the basis for the Miami New Times article), then why did he attend Nova Scotia Community College?

There are too many holes in your theory.

So let's just re-state the facts here: Binksternet fails to do proper diligence on the IP edit using the "whois" link for IP addresses on Wikipedia, and then accuses me of being that editor.

He then fails to critically analyse the Miami New Times source which depends on the allhiphop.com interview which clearly has inaccuracies, and then deduces that Storch is American on the basis of a video where it seems there is a lot of alcohol and mind-altering substances present.

That video is looks like it was shot in a basement. A better source is required.

There are too many inaccuracies in your statements, Binksternet. And your failure to use the whois function on wikipedia, to realise that 24.222.161.49 is from Nova Scotia, and not Alberta, is suggestive of bias. This is basic stuff. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 70.74.141.203 (talk) 20:11, 31 July 2019 (UTC)

• The above, from I have an issue with User:Binksternet who reverted my edits ... downwards, was copypasted from this DRN thread by 70.74.141.203 (talk) at 23:37, 31 July 2019 (UTC). Some of it, particularly the part under the #Talk: Scott Storch subheading, was itself copypasted from elsewhere to DRN, without attribution. --Redrose64 🌹 (talk) 09:40, 1 August 2019 (UTC)

  I have found that the main part goes back further, to this ANI post. There is far too much violation of WP:CWW going on here. --Redrose64 🌹 (talk) 09:50, 1 August 2019 (UTC)

Hello @RedRose64:, I apologise for the WP:CWW, however the content matter has been updated throughout the brief discourse that unsurprisingly ended after my rebuttal to Binksternet. I am sorry for the nuisance but I knew it was going to end up at ANI, and it sure seems it is going that way. In light of that...

Paging Mr @Robert McClenon:, what do you propose my next course of action be? should I relist the dispute on DR, or would you be alright with me moving to ANI to get this issue resolved? I feel Binkster is avoiding the matter given some pretty glaring deficiencies in some of his response (which you could reasonably say were unfounded accusations). — Preceding unsigned comment added by 70.74.141.203 (talk) 18:18, 2 August 2019 (UTC)

My advice is to register an account, be civil, and resume discussion. Before going to WP:ANI, read the boomerang essay. Is there a reason why you choose not to register an account? Some of us have found it very hard to engage in dispute resolution with an IP address. Robert McClenon (talk) 17:02, 3 August 2019 (UTC)

Hello again Mr. @Robert McClenon:. I do not have an account because I am not too keen on editing wikipedia due to these kinds of situations. This is one of those content-related matters that motivated me to make an edit. To be fair, I don't think Binksternet's lack of follow-up is at all related to my lack of an account. If I do make an account, would you allow this to go to ANI? As you can see, I followed Binksternet's allegations cordially and stayed on topic. I'm looking to now escalate the matter to correct the record.

An aside: if Storch wasn't Canadian, then the ~9 years this incorrect information has been here (due to one article and a very unreliable online website) should have been ample for reliable sources (like Source and XXL magazines, plus Noisey) to use this information, but it was not since it is _wrong_. All I want is the evidence examined, the matter handled, and the record corrected. I know in my edit histories I rip on my country, but I'd rather be from a loser country capable of producing *a* Scott Storch because it shows why being a loser is okay. We know we don't gotta be world beaters, as long as we can produce one. And we have. His name is Scott Storch. Not Aubrey Graham. 70.74.141.203 (talk) 18:22, 3 August 2019 (UTC)

For an editor who says that they don't want to edit, you are a stubborn disruptive editor. Anyone can go to WP:ANI, but I would advise you to leave it alone. Robert McClenon (talk) 23:06, 3 August 2019 (UTC)

Our friend 70.74.141.203 from Edmonton, Alberta, argues against Scott Storch saying very clearly that he was born on Long Island. The reason? Because the video show is called Drink Champs and involves a lot of drinking. He doesn't go so far as to say that Storch appears drunk in the video, probably because Storch looks and sounds quite sober, showing the weakness of the argument. The cited segment of the video is four minutes in – a point at which the drinking had just begun, and nobody was drunk yet. Our friend 70.74.141.203 also ignores the many reliable sources supporting the Long Island birth: XXL magazine, New York Post, Wall Street Journal, New York Daily News, Newsday, Tablet magazine, and of course the Miami New Times. Until we have REALLY GOOD sourcing for Canada, explicitly saying that Storch was born in, or even might have been born in Canada, I will treat the matter as a hoax. Binksternet (talk) 00:38, 4 August 2019 (UTC)

Mr @Robert McClenon:, why are you suggesting I "leave it alone"? Even after Binksternet's response, I feel my sources are better and would like to get a few other editors' opinions. Is it reasonable to re-open the WP:DR since we've reached an impasse? And why are you calling me stubborn? Because I don't have an account? What's the big deal about that? I think a fair compromise is to remove mention of Storch's birth place until it's figured out. Additionally, I *think* my sources are newer than Binksternet's (aside from the CBS link I believe they're all post 2014), so I think I have a slight advantage.

Additionally, while its possible Storch attended Nova Scotia Community College as an American, I think it's unlikely as he would have little reason to go there instead of one in, say, Long Island (if I am to believe he was born there).

Here are some additional sources, albeit older ones. Paper Mag Irish Examiner vulture (new York magazine)

Regarding my reticence towards the "drinkchamps", it should be obvious binksternet. Storch has filed court papers saying he's been intimidated by being plied with drugs/alcohol. I just don't see how that sort of notion could be dispelled in that video. He's probably already drunk!

70.74.141.203 (talk) 12:29, 4 August 2019 (UTC)

Either register an account and be civil and discuss, or leave it alone. If you want to edit , be an editor. You can go to wp:ani, but it is not likely to go well. Your call. Robert McClenon (talk) 13:50, 4 August 2019 (UTC)

Earlier I made an argument based on circular sourcing, but apparently I did not start early enough. It looks like this change in September 2006 (from a problematic IP showing disruptive behavior) was the first time the Storch biography was vandalized to say he was from Nova Scotia. So we should be looking at sources published earlier than that, none of which say "Canadian" or born in Nova Scotia. These earlier sources are not delving deep enough into Storch's early life details; they're making assumptions about his birth and focusing instead on Storch's accomplishments. Representative of these is the XXL piece from 2004 which says "Philadelphia native", and The New York Times piece from January 2006 which says "He was born in Brooklyn and grew up in Philadelphia and Fort Lauderdale..." Another example is the Rolling Stone piece from July 2006 which fails to name Storch's birthplace but certainly does not call him Canadian, which would have been worthy of note.

Our most explicit statement of birthplace is still the one directly from Storch's mouth, saying he was born on Long Island. I don't see any compelling reason why we should contradict that. Binksternet (talk) 15:29, 4 August 2019 (UTC)

Hello again @Binksternet:, yes I've noticed those sources too and they also create more of a situation since they're not consistent. My issue with using Storch's own words is that he has argued in court that he has said/done things he did not want to do, in order to make some money. I understand what you're saying, that if we assume he is honest then both the allhiphop.com and drink Champs video "line up". However I think the still storch documentary on vevo is better, and he doesn't mention being born on long Island. He says he learned some piano and went to Philly. I just think, and I don't want to say this here but it's true, it's very difficult to take a recovering addict's word for certain things. I'm not saying in other cases they can't tell the truth, I just think the drink Champs and allhiphop.com responses aren't jiving with his most recent one in Still Storch.

Regarding the circular reference thing, I don't know. What I do know is in the 3 years (which I stated in my first response) that the Nova Scotia location, that it used a source where Brooke Hogan said she didn't know he was canadian. I understand it's possible she read wiki before the source was added and that's how she was "misled" but I don't think wiki was as-popular 13 years as it is now (takes effort and time to build a solid corpus).

I think omitting his birth place for now and just calling him American is a fair compromise, as I feel the vulture/irish examiner/etc sources are reliable enough to create serious doubt about whether he was born in long Island. It makes no sense he'd go to NSCC if he wasn't born there. And I don't know why he'd put that on his linkedin.

Sometimes musicians, especially ones as significant as Storch, do/say things that aren't true due to their impact on a genre. As you can see, this is a testy issue.

I think with our healthy back-and-forth we should be able to take this to DR and see what others think. What say you? 70.74.141.203 (talk) 13:29, 5 August 2019 (UTC)

A healthy back-and-forth means that we don't need dispute resolution.

If I was trying to guess what period of time it was that Storch was fictionalizing his past I would guess that it would be when he was rising up and riding high, not after the big crash and his trying to straighten out. So his later statements would have more credibility. Binksternet (talk) 15:40, 5 August 2019 (UTC)

To be fair @Binksternet:, I don't think that's really the issue because when he was rising up, that's when he was saying he was from Long Island. I suspect much of it to has to due with "street cred" and the fact that most contributors of his stature aren't from Canada, and saying you're from Canada just isn't going to help you at all.

REgarding my desire for dispute resolution, it's because I don't think either of us are going to acknowledge the other's sources. In this case, I think you started off on the wrong foot but slowly added some useful sources. But I honestly feel my sources are of higher quality, and that he Miami New Times article was the article precipitating the change from Canada to the US. I still don't think that's true.

I believe dispute resolution will allow other sets of eyes to comment on the matter and see which one should stand, and in this case there's just two of us right now.

Also, Binksternet, I've called Nova Scotia Community College on this matter. They don't have a central line, but I'm hoping the appropriate student records department could at least confirm his attendance (not sure about if he completed the program), and even better: if they could share what citizenship he attended under.

@Robert McClenon: I've made a username. so what do you recommend? Can I revive the DR post and then put portions of this conversation in it? I feel like the volunteers for DR could add their own thoughts on the matter which would be helpful. StorchBaby (talk) 16:41, 5 August 2019 (UTC)

Binksternet, you said that the information that Storch was born in Halifax NS was added in 2012, but the 2010 Miami New Times article says that in 2008 AP said he was born in Canada. Here's a link to a 2008 CBC article (last updated 2010) that says he was born in Halifax. So we would need an earlier Wikipedia edit to show it was the original source of the information. Also, if Storch actually attended a school in NS, then his claim that he had never been to Canada would be wrong (although Maritimers often use the term to Canada to refer only to the rest of the country.) TFD (talk) 19:31, 13 August 2019 (UTC)

The Four Deuces, there's so much confusing text here on this page I'm not surprised you missed the part where I revised my assessment of circular sourcing to date it back to 2006 with this unreferenced change from a Canadian IP with a history of disruption. Regarding the notion that he attended college in Canada, I'm not at all convinced by the LinkedIn source, which may have been created by anybody, probably NOT Storch, as it doesn't look anything like the LinkedIn page of someone as widely experienced and massively connected as Storch. If Storch was really running that LinkedIn page it would list many more projects as well as hundreds of endorsements by others. Binksternet (talk) 20:02, 13 August 2019 (UTC)

Sable Island is an obvious hoax - only horses are born there as the NS IP who added the information would know. Do you know when Halifax was added? TFD (talk) 20:47, 13 August 2019 (UTC)

Unless someone can show an original adequately sourced mention that Storch was born in Halifax, I think the determining rule is Context matters. Since where Storch was born was of little or no relevance to the sources that say he was born there, it is reasonable to assume that they could have relied on faulty information. TFD (talk) 21:02, 13 August 2019 (UTC)

The Four Deuces I understand the CBS source is a little old, but the XXL and source references are much newer and you have to think they'd consult wikipedia. I don't think Storch is able to be as open about as his birthplace as he'd like to be, but certainly the sources I've provided (both new and old) do present a compelling case he was born in Nova Scotia. I agree it is of little relevance to who he is, but it matters to me.

I want to also note that XXL after-the-fact inappropriately edited Storch's birth place from Nova Scotia to Long Island between June 2018 and now. Sidney Madden seems to no longer be with XXL so obviously someone made an inappropriate edit without her permission. I think this is becoming uglier and uglier by the day, as the truth becomes clearer.

— Preceding unsigned comment added by StorchBaby (talk • contribs) 19:08, 17 August 2019 (UTC)

It seems to me that the first news sources that mentions his place of birth used this Wikipedia article and subsequent reports have used either this article or previous news sources. Storch's family on both sides was from NY. It's possible his father lived temporarily in Halifax but there's nothing to support it. The fact that Storch's place of birth was originally Sable Island (!) shows that it was an obvious hoax. I mentioned "context matters." In none of the sources that say he was born in Halifax has his place of birth in any way relevant to the article. Hence we would not expect any fact-checking. When place of birth is relevant to other Canadian born Americans - Ted Cruz, Pamela Anderson, Walter Huston, Michael J. Fox = we get more information. For example there are stories about Cruz renouncing his Canadian citizenship and Fox acquiring U.S. citizenship. TFD (talk) 16:03, 20 August 2019 (UTC)

The assertion "I don't think Storch is able to be as open about as his birthplace as he'd like to be" is ridiculous and unfounded. We should be trusting the words that come of Storch's own mouth, and we should trust the Miami New Times reporter who talked to Storch's mother before printing the article that says Storch was born on Long Island. Storch and his mother – these are the two people who know best, and they have spoken. Binksternet (talk) 17:17, 20 August 2019 (UTC)

From what I see, Storch has also said he was from Nova Scotia via this press release from his own company. And as far as what Deuces stated, the same allegation can be made about his birth in the US. I've seen some sources say he's from Brooklyn. I haven't seen anything say he's from Sable Island. Just Nova Scotia. I think we should start a fresh RfC on the DR and see what happens. To say that IMDB would still have it listed incorrectly after 9 years, in which there were very likely people who said it was wrong, isn't appropriate. Yes it can get things wrong, but I don't think they'd deliberately leave up the wrong birth place. Especially after this topic was first started 9 years ago. StorchBaby (talk) 13:31, 24 August 2019 (UTC)

That press release has two sections, one from Storch's company, and one from an editor who describes Storch's career. The bit about being from Canada is in the editor's section, not from Storch himself. In any case, prweb is not reliable for facts about a person, nor is imdb. Binksternet (talk) 14:59, 24 August 2019 (UTC)

That is incorrect. That bit, I believe, is something the company itself has the option of providing when releasing it. I am in the process of seeing if I can find recent contact information for Storch's previous PR representative, Mrs. Holly Jordano (now Harper). Gonna have to give me a few days. Got my hands full doin' some shit, binks. — Preceding unsigned comment added by StorchBaby (talk • contribs)

I don't see why you think it will help if you look up Storch's PR folks. Public relations releases on prweb are not considered reliable enough to settle controversial matters related to a WP:BLP. And talking to PR folks to get their opinion is a violation of WP:NOR. You still don't have anything to contradict Storch's mother who was interviewed by the Miami New Times, and told the reporter about Storch's family history. That same reporter published an article a few months later titled "Scott Storch is Not Canadian." How much plainer does it have to be? Binksternet (talk) 23:11, 27 August 2019 (UTC)

Binks, there are two points here that you continually keep ignoring. So I will spell them out here for you since your selective responses are not conducive.

1. the allhiphop.com interview is not legitimate. It is not a reliable source, nor was it ever. I do not see how your continual reliance on what you claim to be a reliable source (Miami New Times) is sufficient "cover" (if you will) for the illegitimacy of "allhiphop.com".
   That is, even if a news outlet such as MNT is considered a reliable source, they were NOT the ones who conducted the interview, and relied on a highly questionable website as their source.
   The practice of an alleged reliable source (if I accept MNT as one) does not validate an unreliable source, which is allhip.com. This is very simple.
   Throwing out the fraudulent allhiphop.com interview, which we have no evidence of ever occurring aside from their dodgy website (would Storch really grant them an interview if he refused Gus Garcia? I have my doubts)....
2. you do realise your strongest evidence are primary sources, right? Per "how to classify a source", your strongest points are not admissible for a biography.

User:StorchBaby - Has User:Binksternet said that you can call them "Binks" or by some other familiar or pet name? If not, please don't; it is overly familiar and a violation of civility. Robert McClenon (talk) 19:53, 6 September 2019 (UTC)

Both the proclamation and the diary are primary sources. These primary sources have advantages: they were written at the time, and so are free of the opinions and fictions imposed by later generations. They also have disadvantages: the proclamation might contain propaganda designed to pacify the conquered country, or omit politically inconvenient facts, or overstate the importance of other facts, or be designed to stroke the new ruler's ego. The diary will reflect the prejudices of its author, and its author might be unaware of relevant facts.

That is, the statements of Storch himself must be considered as unreliable. It is no different than when, say, a Band claims a certain musician was a large influence. For example, Barry Gibb influenced a lot of people in music. But, just because one artist claims Gibb heavily influenced them, it does not make it fact. I believe secondary sources here will rule. StorchBaby (talk) 17:39, 4 September 2019 (UTC)

I have no idea why you think the Miami New Times articles would be or should be considered unreliable based on your opinion of allhiphop.com. First off, our reliability guide WP:WikiProject Albums/Sources lists allhiphop.com as reliable. Second, the reporter from the Miami New Times did his own investigation, including interviewing Yolanda Storch, Scott's mother. Both of the articles from the Miami New Times are perfectly good WP:SECONDARY sources, which is in a stark contrast to your gross misrepresentation of them. Take your hoax somewhere else. Binksternet (talk) 18:43, 4 September 2019 (UTC)

Birthplace Dispute

Okay, this has been going on for a long time, and may go on until the Year 2038 problem causes Wikipedia to disappear. User:StorchBaby - You posted a poorly formed RFC about this birthplace that wasn't framed in a way that was likely to get an answer. It expired. Legobot pulled the RFC tag because it had expired. You put the tag back. Legobot pulled the tag again. Don't get into an edit-war with a bot. The bot wins. Stop asking about going to WP:ANI, unless you think that User:Binksternet is guilty of a conduct violation. If you want to use an RFC and don't know how, ask for assistance in filing a neutrally worded RFC. Otherwise discuss here, on this talk page. Okay. Do you want to continue discussing, or do you want an RFC, or do you want to have edit-warring (but that isn't permitted), or what? Robert McClenon (talk) 19:16, 4 September 2019 (UTC)

Is not being accused of vandalism, and having edits reverted on that basis (solely) a conduct violation? are the continual insinuations that i'm somehow feeding a "hoax" not conduct violations? he has trouble accepting the entirety of evidence, instead he selectively responds to parts that he feels give him the strongest argument.

You closed the discussion on the basis that the RFC superceded it, but the RFC yielded nothing.

So my question to you is: are we allowed to revive the dispute resolution thread, given that RFC did not yield fruit? i do not think RFC will help at this tme since no one cares about this artist except probably me.

There must be an avenue for proper resolution of this matter. StorchBaby (talk) 17:08, 5 September 2019 (UTC)

Now following up on Binksternet's claims: Again, Binksternet is selective his response (above Mr. McClenon), refusing to acknowledge the faulty nature of both of his primary sources he relied heavily upon (the video(s) and Storch's own statements, from what Binks claims). He now pivots to allhiphop.com being a reliable source, which is NOT clear at all.

Consulting WP:WikiProject Albums/Sources, I see that allhiphop was mentioned ONCE, and it really is not the focus of the discussion. Spellcast i would appreciate your input here, as i think this alleged interview is not real.

Additionally, I saw followup comments that don't really justify binksternet's claim that allhiphop.com is a reliable source. All Spellcast says is that allhiphop is reliable since it's used by noteworthy publications, but that doesn't mean much because this is, again, a primary source (allhiphop.com's own words of what they are, and why we should care/why they are legitimate).

As an example of allhiophop's unreliability, if I look at allhiphop.com's article discussing a potential collaboration between mill and storch, we are told he is collaborating with "fellow Philadelphia native" (Mill).

IF they had conducted this interview, as Binksternet believes, then such contradictions should be unacceptable. Especially for them to get an interview that could only described as the "shocking truth"

Looking at allhiphop.com's articles on Storch, they are at best questionable. For example, they speak of an exclusive interview in 2013 that i have difficulty finding.

It is certainly not linked when I use Safari 10.1.2 or Firefox (with Noscript, but allowing the mavendigital/maven/allhiphop.com domains)

Maybe allhiphop.com's reliability needs to be re-evaluated. I don't think a website's "about us" description, plus the statements of a few people (Russell Simmons, Jim Farber [a pop music critic], and the manager of Eminem) are a sufficient basis for a source being reliable. To me, allhiphop.com just feels like an hip hop news aggregator.

Lastly, about Storch's mother: She has, in the past few years, come out and insulted Storch for his lack of financial support. So to me, I don't think mentioning her is of any help. She too, may have her own biases.

In closing, let's roll the dice for one second. Let me pretend allhiphop.com is reliable, then is the interview STILL not a secondary source since it relies SOLELY on the assumption that the person being interviewed is telling the truth!

IF we are to accept allhiphop.com as a reliable source, then we must also acknowledge that this interview is more primary than secondary since again it uses only Storch's statements to state he is born in America.

If that alleged interview from allhiphop real, they did no additional checking of their own, nor did they ask him for any information to legitimise his statement. They merely reprinted what he said, which is still a primary source. StorchBaby (talk) 17:08, 5 September 2019 (UTC)

You don't understand the word "reliable" as used in WP:Reliable sources. The Miami New Times pieces are examples of good reportorial work, published by a professional journalist working for an established newspaper. That's what makes it reliable. We rely on the reporter sifting the wheat from the chaff, and the reporter concludes Storch was born on Long Island. The reporter also says that the persistence of the Wikipedia-based hoax messed up the historic record, which is why we are here now discussing Storch's birthplace.

It continues to be true that no good sources exist to show Storch having a Canada birth. Nobody from his family said that, none of his old neighbors, for instance, nobody who knows his early history. The Canada birth stuff in published sources is very thin soup, unsupported by any early life details. And the chronology of each Canada source shows that Wikipedia was hosting the hoax version at the time, every time.

I'm out of here, guys. I've said all I intend to say about the matter. But I will not allow the hoax back in to the biography. Binksternet (talk) 23:42, 5 September 2019 (UTC)

Robert McClenon as you can see, Binksternet again ignores the brunt of the argument and focuses on what he feels will strengthen his side. He claims that Miami New Times is a reliable source for reporting a primary source without additional informatino. In fact, they did no fact checking of their own and claim his mother said he's not Canadian.

It doesn't matter what Storch's mother says, as she is not reliable. Furthermore, you can see Binksternet avoid the real issue which is that the Miami New Times piece did NOT report anything other than allhiphop.com's interview.

It does not continue to be true that no good sources report Storch being Canadian. You have seen Mr McClenon lean on my side during the DR< and then conveniently came back with more sources that did not strengthen your point at all.

You now hang on a primary source that was regurgitated by an alleged reliable source, where neither of the two venues did their own research.

us Garcia Roberts did NOT research whether Storch is Canadian.

IN FACT even HE has now opened the door that his reporting was erroneous: see tweet here that shows Roberts is lacking conviction in his own alleged "reporting".

What is clear, is that Binksternet does not play nice with others and refuses to engage in a proper exchange where he acknowledges some sources and rebuts them. His style is very much to selectively respond. edit: Mr McClenon, what is obvious here is that Binksternet has been on his heels defending his egregious conduct and now has stated "I will revert the factual basis of Storch being born in Canada, without responding further on this matter". To me, this is a whole new level.

It is one thing to exchange ideas, it is entirely another to continually reject one side's sources (which are more reliable than his) and state they will revert such edits regardless. I have not witnessed this type of conduct and I believe we are getting close to further conduct violations.

Can we re-open the DR, please? StorchBaby (talk) 16:25, 6 September 2019 (UTC)

Reply to User:Binksternet and User:StorchBaby

The above is a little hard to read, because it is hard to tell what portions are written by whom. I am not going to try to go back through the history and parse the origins. I can see an unproductive exchange. Robert McClenon (talk) 20:59, 6 September 2019 (UTC)

Reply to User:StorchBaby

I certainly have no idea what I would be accomplishing by re-opening the DR. As a volunteer moderator at DRN, I have no special power or authority. I also see that you, User:StorchBaby, are mostly commenting on User:Binksternet more than on content. Comment on content, not contributors. I do not resolve conduct disputes. You have the right to go to WP:ANI, but you may not get a friendly hearing if you are mostly complaining without alleging any specific conduct violation.

Your best course of action at this point might be a neutral properly worded RFC, but the last time that we were discussing an RFC, you went ahead and published one that didn't ask a specific question. Your choices now seem to be: further discussion here, but I don't think that Binksternet wants to discuss; another DR, but I won't re-open it if Binksternet doesn't want to discuss and you are being insulting; another DR with another volunteer, but you might not get a volunteer and you might not get the other party; or a neutral properly worded RFC. Your call. Robert McClenon (talk) 20:59, 6 September 2019 (UTC)

---

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Canadian hoaxer

User:StorchBaby was blocked as a sockpuppet. But according to my findings which I reported at Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard/IncidentArchive1017#Off-wiki harassment of newspaper reporter, birthplace hoax regarding Scott Storch, it appears that StorchBaby was trying very hard to damage the Storch biography for personal reasons. The original hoaxer may or may not have been StorchBaby using an IP address, but the continuing defense of the hoax was definitely carried on by StorchBaby and IP 70.74.141.203.

Regarding the discussion above which was closed as inconclusive, I think the evidence is very conclusive that Storch was born in New York on Long Island, and that some very angry person from Canada perpetrated a hoax claiming Canadian birth. Binksternet (talk) 00:30, 25 May 2021 (UTC)